Cast of Heathers: the Musical Film
Ms. Fleming is the clueless teacher, played by Michelle Duffy. She gets a huge musical number called “Shine a Light.” It’s the cringiest, most well-intentioned attempt at school spirit ever.
Michelle Duffy is a powerhouse comedian. She makes Ms. Fleming so earnestly dumb that you can’t hate her. You just want to give her a coffee and a reality check.
The Principal is played by Daniel Everidge. He has like, two lines. But he delivers them with the weary eyes of a man who has seen a freshman cry over a Pop Tart. We respect that.
‘Heathers the Musical’ Touring Australia April 2026 — The Note - Your
The Background Weirdos (The Best Part)
The film cast a wide net for the “student body.” You’ll spot actors from the original Off-Broadway run in tiny roles. It’s like a scavenger hunt for theater nerds.
Watch for the Preps, the Goths, and the Scunts (sporty sluts). Each group has a distinct look and a sassy comment. The casting director nailed building a world that feels both fake and painfully real.
One extra is literally credited as “Student with Tic.” That’s the level of detail here. Nobody escapes the weirdness.