Mac and Cheese Noodles Types
Let’s start with the MVP: the humble elbow macaroni. Those little curved tubes are the standard for a reason. They’re small and easy for little hands to scoop up, but they also trap cheese in their little “elbow” pockets.
I remember my grandma’s boxed mac and cheese. She’d always use the classic elbows, and somehow, every single bite had that perfect balance of pasta and orange goodness. It’s dependable, like an old friend who always shows up on time.
But here’s a secret: elbows can sometimes get a bit soggy if you overcook them. So, set that timer! Al dente is your friend; you want a little chew to hold up against all that gooey sauce.
The Curly Ones: Cavatappi & Rotini
Now, if you want to get fancy without leaving your kitchen, say hello to cavatappi. These are those fun, corkscrew-shaped noodles that look like little telephone cords. They are magnificent at holding sauce.
Picture this: you’re making a baked mac and cheese with crispy breadcrumbs on top. Using cavatappi means every twist and spiral is filled with creamy cheddar. You get a burst of cheese in every single bite. It’s a game-changer.
Another great curly option is rotini, those little spirals. They’re a bit smaller and tighter, which makes them perfect for stovetop mac. They grab the sauce like tiny hands holding onto a treasure. Your kids will think it’s a bouncy, fun dinner, not just noodles.
We Tried 9 Boxed Mac and Cheeses—Find Out the Best
The Tube Stars: Ziti & Penne
Don’t be afraid to raid your pantry for ziti or penne. These larger tubes are usually for bakes, but they’re incredible in mac and cheese. They’re thick and hearty, giving you a satisfying chew.
Think of them as the sturdy, reliable friends who don’t fall apart under pressure. When you bake a ziti mac, the sauce gets inside the tube too. It’s like a cheese-filled surprise waiting for you at the end of your fork.
Penne, with its angled ends, is especially good because it acts like a little shovel. It scoops up extra sauce from the bottom of the bowl. It’s perfect for those days when you want a “cold lunch” leftover the next day.
The Wild Cards: Shells & Orzo
Okay, let’s get a little unconventional. Have you tried shell pasta? Those little seashells are like tiny boats for cheese. They hold a ton of sauce in their little cavity.
My friend Sarah makes a lobster mac with shells, and it’s legendary. But even without the lobster, plain old shells turn a simple dinner into something special. It feels more like a restaurant meal than a Tuesday night.
And then there’s orzo. Yes, the tiny rice-shaped pasta. Use it in mac and cheese, and you get a creamy, risotto-like texture. It feels indulgent and fancy, but you can make it in fifteen minutes. Your spoon will thank you.
We Tried 18 Boxes of Mac and Cheese to Find the Very Best